We have just listened to a concert featuring the world premiere of Riegger's Sinfonietta. But what about the other composers on the program? It turns out that William Richards, Walter Scotson, Gerald Wilfring Gore, John H. McCurdy, Edwin Farell, and others are all pseudonyms for Riegger himself. Riegger reflects on his method of composition, saying the music comes by "fits and starts, mostly starts." In the case of the Sinfonietta he took a bunch of these starts, "good beginnings that went nowhere and up and finished them." Having had a unique career, alternating between the classical and modernist styles, he compares himself to Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. "A large part of my thinking is old-fashioned," he confesses. But then there is the demon in him that composes in the twelve tone scale as well. The interviewer notes that while he used to be referred to as the Dean of American Music now that title is more often bestowed on Aaron Copeland. Reigger, in his seventies, does not seem miffed, mildly observing, "Doesn't matter what a person is called, it's what he does." One leaves with the impression of a still-working artist, approaching the end of his career, at peace with his achievement.
The career of Wallingford Riegger (1885-1961) illustrates the danger of pigeonholing creative artists. An early success as both a cellist and conductor, he studied in Germany and began composing during the Twenties. While he did come under the influence of Arnold Schoenberg via Schoenberg's American student Adolph Weiss, there is evidence that he had already sought out his own path before encountering the twelve tone system. As music critic Kyle Gann notes in Arts Journal:
Riegger wrote an astonishing Study in Sonority in 1928, more radical to my ears than anything Schoenberg had yet done, and attractive Third and Fourth Symphonies and a Piano Concerto all in a 12-tone idiom, and also a beautifully retro Canon and Fugue in old-fashioned D minor.
In the 1930's Riegger started composing dance for music for Martha Graham as well as Jose Limon, Doris Humphrey and Hanya Holmes. New Dance, by choreographed by Humphrey, is considered by some to be first genuinely modern dance. Performances of his orchestral work were rare, but he did find appreciation within the classical music community. As the website Pytheas Music summarizes:
American composer Wallingford Riegger was a proponent of none of the major twentieth century "schools" of composition, and until the very end of his long career he received little more than cursory notice from the American musical establishment. Nevertheless, his 75 completed compositions have proved a source of enrichment to several generations of musicians who are drawn to Riegger's unique brand of modernism.
Some of this neglect may have been due to Riegger's relationship with the Communist Party. He refused to answer questions about his alleged membership before the HUAC Committee. He found more acceptance towards the end of his life, as this performance and interview attest to. Baker's Biographical Dictionary, cited on the Bach Cantatas website, tells how:
…after a long period of neglect on the part of the public and the critics, Riegger began to receive recognition. Several dance works, cast in more strictly neoromantic idioms, brought popular success as did his 3rd Symphony, which won a Naumburg Foundation Recording Award and was the choice of the New York Music Critics' Circle in 1948. … In 1958, Leonard Bernstein honored him by conducting his Music for Orchestra with the New York Philharmonic Orchestra.
It's a stretch, but one could whimsically relate Riegger's efforts to bridge the harsh relations between the camps of classicism and modernism to his unusual death. Coming upon two fighting dogs, the composer tripped over their leashes and received a head injury which proved fatal.
Audio courtesy of the NYC Municipal Archives WNYC Collection.
WNYC archives id: 150257
Municipal archives id: LT9101